Careful What You Wish For

Nick Jonas

Doug Martin

Kiki Harris

Emily Martin

David Sherrill

Brian Martin

Graham Rogers

Carson

Paul Sorvino

Sheriff Big Jack

John Driskell Hopkins

Gus

Marc Macaulay

Gordon

Isabel Lucas

Lena Harper

Dermot Mulroney

Elliot Harper

Jay Potter

Richard

Kevin L. Johnson

Rent a Cop

Leon Pridgen

Deputy Lem Kawalski

Kandyse McClure

Angie Alvarez

Ross Gallo

Lena's Lawyer

Beth Adams

Restaurant Patron

Sierra Alexander

Beach Babe, Flirty bar patron with Doug

Alex ter Avest

Emma Shalloway

Rob C. Baldwin

Restaurant Patron

Kristi Booher

Diner Patron

Betsy Brown

Janice